Government establishes committee to enhance NTA amid NEET, UGC-NET controversies
New Delhi: TThe Union government made a significant announcement on Thursday, stating that a high-level committee would be formed with the purpose of providing recommendations for improving the structure, processes, data management, and security protocols of the National Testing Agency (NTA). This decision was prompted by the occurrence of controversies surrounding two crucial national-level examinations.
The committee will consist of technocrats, scientists, educational administrators, scholars, and psychologists.
The education minister, Dharmendra Pradhan, emphasized the government’s dedication to refining the education system and ensuring transparency. He reiterated their commitment to preventing malpractices and irregularities, assuring the public of the government’s determination to secure a better future for students.
Also Read |
Pradhan clarified that the government has not yet decided to cancel NEET-UG 2024, unlike the UGC-NET exam for teaching jobs. He referred to NEET-related issues as “isolated incidents” under police investigation. The NEET-UG 2024 results have sparked controversy nationwide, with numerous aspirants achieving perfect scores of 720, indicating irregularities.
The ministry’s announcement came after they decided earlier in the week to cancel the University Grants Commission–National Eligibility Test (NET) due to concerns regarding the exam’s integrity.
Need for action
In Bihar, four NEET aspirants arrested for their involvement in a paper leak have reportedly confessed that the question paper was leaked on the eve of the 5 May exam. The gang allegedly charged up to ₹32 lakh for the leaked material. The NEET fiasco has prompted a string of petitions across various courts of the country, including at the Supreme Court.
While some said the setting up of a committee was not enough, others welcomed the move.
“We believe this action is insufficient and merely an attempt to cool down the issue. The SIO demands a thorough Special Investigation Team probe under the guidance of the Supreme Court to ensure a transparent and unbiased investigation…,” said Roshan Mohiddin, national secretary of the Student Islamic Organisation (SIO), one of the petitioners in the case.
“This is a welcome step. However, a balancing act is required. Responsibilities must be fixed and the guilty must be punished. We need to remember that there are lakhs of innocent students who have put in a lot of hard work; they must not be subjected to this ordeal again if leaks are region-specific. In that case, there should be only a limited re-NEET,” said advocate Charu Mathur, one of the petitioners’ lawyers in the case.
UGC-NET cancellation
Regarding the cancellation of UGC-NET, Pradhan stated, “The decision was based on credible evidence of questions being available on the darknet, compromising the exam’s integrity.” According to Pradhan, the question paper that was circulated on the social media platform, Telegram, matched with the original question paper.
On the Bihar incident, Pradhan added, “In the context of the NEET exam, we are in contact with the Bihar government and are receiving updates from Patna. The Patna police are investigating, and strict action will be taken based on credible information.”
SC declined to stay the counselling
Meanwhile, the Supreme Court declined to stay the counselling process for students who cleared the controversial NEET-UG 2024 exam for admissions into undergraduate medical courses. Justices Vikram Nath and S.V.N. Bhatti of a vacation bench stated, “If the exam proceeds, counselling will also continue.”
The Supreme Court also halted proceedings related to paper leak allegations in Rajasthan, Calcutta, and Bombay High Courts, responding to an NTA plea to transfer these cases to the apex court.
The Supreme Court will now hold a comprehensive hearing on 8 July.
Various discrepancies in this year’s NEET exam were highlighted during the hearing. One lawyer highlighted the unprecedented number of 67 students scoring full marks of 720, prompting calls for scrutiny of their academic backgrounds. Other lawyers raised the issue of students losing significant exam time at a Meghalaya test centre and allegations of incorrect multiple-choice questions (MCQs).
Following the release of the NEET 2024 results on 4 June, numerous discrepancies came to light, notably the unprecedented occurrence of 67 students achieving perfect scores of 720/720. Questions were raised regarding the legitimacy of these scores, especially with reports that six students from a single centre in Haryana achieved perfect scores.
In response to these controversies, several petitions were filed. The Students Islamic Organisation of India (SIO) challenged the results, demanding a fresh examination. Alakh Pandey, CEO of Physics Wallah that coaches aspirants for medical and engineering admission tests, filed a petition contesting the arbitrary awarding of grace marks to approximately 1,500 students.
Other petitions highlighted score discrepancies, statistical anomalies, and called for reevaluation of OMR sheets without grace marks, forensic audits, and nullification of specific NTA announcements. Additionally, there were calls for a CBI investigation into alleged paper leaks, particularly focused on the Jai Jalaram School in Gujarat.
On 13 June, the government informed the Supreme Court of its decision to withdraw grace marks given to 1,536 students, providing them with revised scores and the option to reappear for the exam on 23 June.
Subsequently, on 14 June, the Supreme Court issued notices to the Centre and the NTA in response to a CBI inquiry into the alleged paper leak.
Approximately 2.4 million candidates had participated in the entrance exam held on 5 May across 571 cities, including 14 centres located outside India.